This is a palette of 10 neutral matte shadows plus one grey eyeliner.
Top Row (Left to Right): Air, Wind, Desert, Clay, Earth
Bottom Row (Left to Right): Driftwood, Fire, Rain, Smoke, Ebony
Left to Right: Earth, Clay, Desert, Wind, Air
Left to Right: Ebony, Smoke, Rain, Fire, Driftwood
Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner in Halfmoon
While this palette does not get much publicity, it is a great matte palette. It contains a great range of neutral shades, both cool and warm tones, and the pigmentation is really good. These colors can be used all over the lid, to deepen the crease, as liner or as a blending color.
My two favorite shades are clay and rain. I like to wear clay all over the lid and rain in the crease and outer corner for an everyday neutral eye.
My one issue is the eyeliner. The mechanism to turn the liner is not very good. It takes a lot to wind up the liner. The pigmentation is great though.
The palette retails for $39, the same as the other Stila eyeshadow palettes. It is available at Sephora, Ulta and stilacosmetics.com.
If you are looking for an all matte palette, definitely check this one out.